🏆 Australian Call Centre Rankings · Q3 2026

Australian Car Insurers Q3 2026 Call Centre Rankings

Car insurance is easy to compare on price and hard to compare on anything else. The phone call is often the only evidence a customer has of how an insurer will treat them on the day they need to claim.

We mystery shop Australia's car insurers as customers taking out a new policy or comparing cover before they switch, and score every call against 48+ CX metrics aligned to the ACXPA Contact Centre CX Standards. Nobody is told when we are calling.

Overall CX

The headline score: getting through and the conversation, combined

61.0%

▲ 4.5 pts on Q2 · best on record

Accessibility

How easily callers reached a real person

67.3%

▲ 4.5 pts on Q2 · best on record

Agent Mastery

How well agents handled the conversation

59.7%

▲ 3.8 pts on Q2 · best on record

National ranking

Car insurance's Overall CX against the other sectors we benchmark

3rd

of 7 sectors · all-industry 59.0%

The quarter in one line: car insurance's best quarter on record, with record highs on all three headline scores and the strongest Agent Mastery of any sector we benchmark.

↑ Report sections
🏆 Australian Car Insurers Leaderboard – Q3 2026

Recognising Call Centre Excellence for Australian Car Insurers

Congratulations to Youi, which leads Australian car insurance for a sixth consecutive quarter and tops both Overall CX and Agent Mastery.

In a market where a comparison site is one click away, the insurers at the top of this table are winning the customers their competitors lose in the phone menu and the conversation.

Overall Winner — #1 Ranked Call Centre, Australian Car Insurers
🏆 BEST CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE
Australian Car Insurers - Q3 2026Australia’s Leading Car Insurers by Contact Centre CX Score on new policy enquiries — combining Accessibility (how easily customers get through) and Agent Mastery (how well they’re helped).
1st:Youi logo 71.7%
2nd:Budget Direct logo 64.3%
3rd:RACV logo 62.0%
Lowest:AAMI logo 53.9%
🎯 Call Centre CX Quadrant – Q3 2026

Call Centre CX Quadrant – Australian Car Insurers Q3 2026

The quadrant plots Accessibility (how easily a caller reaches a live agent) against Agent Mastery (how well the conversation is handled). It shows the top three and lowest three insurers on Overall CX this quarter.

The chart tells the quarter's story. All six insurers shown sit in "easy to reach, strong conversation", above 50% on both measures. Accessibility sits in a narrow band, from 56.2% for AAMI to 72.8% for Budget Direct.

What separates them is the conversation. Youi's Agent Mastery of 73.7% is 13.0 points clear of the next insurer shown, Budget Direct (60.7%). RACV made the biggest move: its Accessibility rose from 46.2% to 67.0% and its Agent Mastery from 45.6% to 59.9%, taking it out of "hard to reach, weak conversation".

No insurer we benchmark reached the Best Practice zone. The next gain for the sector is the opening of the call.

Australian Call Centre Rankings · Q3 2026

Contact Centre CX Quadrant

Australian Car Insurers · New car insurance quote enquiries

Hover or tap a number to see who it is
BESTPRACTICEEASY TO REACHWEAK CONVERSATIONEASY TO REACHSTRONG CONVERSATIONHARD TO REACHWEAK CONVERSATIONHARD TO REACHSTRONG CONVERSATION01020304050607080901000102030405060708090100Agent Mastery (%) →Accessibility (%) →654321
Top three
1Youi71.7%Access 67.1%
Mastery 73.7%
2Budget Direct64.3%Access 72.8%
Mastery 60.7%
3RACV62.0%Access 67.0%
Mastery 59.9%
Lowest three
4NRMA57.8%Access 67.3%
Mastery 58.5%
5Allianz56.3%Access 67.4%
Mastery 51.5%
6AAMI53.9%Access 56.2%
Mastery 57.6%
↑ Accessibility (up the chart)

How quickly and easily a caller gets through to a real person: phone menus, recorded messages, wait time, and whether the call is answered at all.

→ Agent Mastery (across the chart)

How well the agent handles the call once answered: understanding what the caller needs, explaining options clearly, and checking the caller is ready to proceed.

★ The goal: top right

Easy to reach and a strong conversation. Insurers in the Best Practice corner score 80%+ on both.

91+ Outstanding76–90 Exceeds61–75 Meets45–60 Below<45 Poor

Shows a selection of the car insurers ACXPA benchmarks, not every insurer in the sector. Scores are the quarter average of independent mystery shopping calls, rated against the ACXPA Contact Centre CX Standards.

📋 The Quarter in Review – Q3 2026

Australian Car Insurers · Q3 2026

The Quarter in Review

Australian car insurance posted its best quarter on record. Overall CX averaged 61.0%, up 4.5 points on Q2 and ahead of the previous best of 58.7% in Q3 2025.

Both halves of the score set records. Accessibility rose 4.5 points to 67.3%, as the average wait fell from 1:31 to 0:57 and the time to reach a person from 3:26 to 2:49. Agent Mastery rose 3.8 points to 59.7%, a third consecutive gain.

The table tightened. Youi led for a sixth consecutive quarter at 71.7%. RACV (+22.9 points) climbed from last to third, the second-largest single-quarter gain we have measured for a car insurer, and Budget Direct posted its best result to date (64.3%) to finish second.

At the bottom, AAMI finished last at 53.9%, with the sector’s lowest Accessibility (56.2%). The 17.8 point gap between first and last is the narrowest we have recorded for the sector, down from 31.2 points in Q2.

📊 How car insurance compares nationally · Overall CX, Q3 2026

Internet
67.2%
Energy
61.1%
Car Insurance
61.0%
Councils
60.2%
Education
56.4%
Aged Care
56.4%
Banks
52.3%

Car insurance ranked third of the seven sectors, 2.0 points above the all-industry average of 59.0% and a tenth of a point behind energy.

Its Agent Mastery (59.7%) is the highest of any sector for a second consecutive quarter. Its Accessibility (67.3%) sits just below the all-industry average of 68.8%.

📊 Q3 2026 Scorecard

Every headline measure at a glance

📊 Q3 2026 Scorecard – Australian Car Insurers

The sector average for each measure, how it moved since Q2, and the best and weakest insurer results this quarter.

See the weakest insurer on every measure, free. Subscribers unlock the full scorecard.

Subscribe free
MeasureSector avgvs Q2Best in sectorWeakest in sectorYour insurer
Headline scores
Overall CX61.0%▲ 4.5 pts
71.7%
🔒 Free sign-up🔒
Accessibility67.3%▲ 4.5 pts
73.1%
🔒 Free sign-up🔒
Agent Mastery59.7%▲ 3.8 pts
73.7%
🔒 Free sign-up🔒
Getting through
Calls answered within 10 minutes96.8%▲ 1.6 pts
Several insurers tied ▾100.0%
🔒 Free sign-up🔒
Average wait0:57▼ 0:34
0:14
🔒 Free sign-up🔒
Time in phone menu1:53▼ 0:01
1:14
🔒 Free sign-up🔒
Time to reach a person2:49▼ 0:37
2:15
🔒 Free sign-up🔒
Menu layers3.2▼ 0.1
2 insurers tied ▾2.0
🔒 Free sign-up🔒
The conversation
Engage43.1%▲ 4.2 pts
68.1%
🔒 Free sign-up🔒
Discover47.9%▲ 5.6 pts
87.0%
🔒 Free sign-up🔒
Educate67.1%▲ 3.4 pts
75.0%
🔒 Free sign-up🔒
Close58.5%▼ 2.3 pts
70.4%
🔒 Free sign-up🔒
Impact79.8%▲ 4.4 pts
91.7%
🔒 Free sign-up🔒
MeasureSector avgvs Q2Best in sectorWeakest in sectorYour insurer
Headline scores
Overall CX61.0%▲ 4.5 pts
71.7%
53.9%
🔒
Accessibility67.3%▲ 4.5 pts
73.1%
56.2%
🔒
Agent Mastery59.7%▲ 3.8 pts
73.7%
51.5%
🔒
Getting through
Calls answered within 10 minutes96.8%▲ 1.6 pts
Several insurers tied ▾100.0%
2 insurers tied ▾88.9%
🔒
Average wait0:57▼ 0:34
0:14
1:53
🔒
Time in phone menu1:53▼ 0:01
1:14
2:29
🔒
Time to reach a person2:49▼ 0:37
2:15
3:18
🔒
Menu layers3.2▼ 0.1
2 insurers tied ▾2.0
4.6
🔒
The conversation
Engage43.1%▲ 4.2 pts
68.1%
31.9%
🔒
Discover47.9%▲ 5.6 pts
87.0%
31.5%
🔒
Educate67.1%▲ 3.4 pts
75.0%
59.7%
🔒
Close58.5%▼ 2.3 pts
70.4%
50.0%
🔒
Impact79.8%▲ 4.4 pts
91.7%
51.4%
🔒

Q3 2026 is the average of July, August and September. Hover over or tap a measure to see what it covers. Average wait and time to reach a person include unanswered calls, counted up to the time limit. Green is better, red is worse.

Where would your insurer sit in this table? Car Insurance Benchmarking scores your own sales line on every one of these measures, alongside the competitors you choose. Plans start from $397 a month.

Add your insurer's column
🚗 Insurer by Insurer – Q3 2026

The stories behind the numbers

🚗 Insurer by Insurer – What Moved in Q3

The top three, and the lowest

Youi
71.7%Overall CX · #1

Leads the sector for a sixth consecutive quarter, and has topped Overall CX in 11 of the 12 quarters we have benchmarked. Its Agent Mastery (73.7%) led for a ninth consecutive quarter.

It set the sector’s best Engage (68.1%) and Discover (87.0%) scores. Access is the gap: its average wait rose from 0:45 to 1:53, the longest in the sector.

Budget Direct
▲ 6.2 ptsOverall CX · now 2nd

Its best-ever Overall CX (64.3%) and a third consecutive quarterly gain. Agent Mastery also reached a best-ever 60.7%, with the sector’s best Educate score (75.0%).

Its average wait fell from 1:58 to 0:16, and callers reached a person in 2:15, the fastest in the sector.

RACV
▲ 22.9 ptsOverall CX · now 3rd

From last to third, the second-largest single-quarter gain we have measured for a car insurer, with best-ever Overall CX, Accessibility and Agent Mastery.

Calls answered within ten minutes rose from 77.8% to 100%, and the average wait fell from 3:05 to 0:54.

AAMI
53.9%Overall CX · lowest

Overall CX slipped 0.5 points, leaving AAMI last. Its Accessibility (56.2%) is the lowest in the sector, and 11.1% of assessed calls weren’t answered within ten minutes.

The conversation is improving: Agent Mastery reached a best-ever 57.6%, with the sector’s best Impact score (91.7%).

🔒 Want to see how other insurers performed? ACXPA Members see the stories for a selection of the car insurers we benchmark, plus provider-level results in the Car Insurance Rankings Dashboard.

Become a member

🔒 Want to see how other insurers performed? ACXPA Members see the stories for a selection of the car insurers we benchmark, plus provider-level results in the Car Insurance Rankings Dashboard.

Upgrade to membership

Stories for a selection of the car insurers we benchmark this quarter.

Leading and climbing

Youi
71.7%Overall CX · #1

Leads the sector for a sixth consecutive quarter, and has topped Overall CX in 11 of the 12 quarters we have benchmarked. Its Agent Mastery (73.7%) led for a ninth consecutive quarter.

It set the sector’s best Engage (68.1%) and Discover (87.0%) scores. Access is the gap: its average wait rose from 0:45 to 1:53, the longest in the sector.

Budget Direct
▲ 6.2 ptsOverall CX · now 2nd

Its best-ever Overall CX (64.3%) and a third consecutive quarterly gain. Agent Mastery also reached a best-ever 60.7%, with the sector’s best Educate score (75.0%).

Its average wait fell from 1:58 to 0:16, and callers reached a person in 2:15, the fastest in the sector.

RACV
▲ 22.9 ptsOverall CX · now 3rd

From last to third, the second-largest single-quarter gain we have measured for a car insurer, with best-ever Overall CX, Accessibility and Agent Mastery.

Calls answered within ten minutes rose from 77.8% to 100%, and the average wait fell from 3:05 to 0:54.

NRMA
▲ 10.0 ptsOverall CX

Best-ever Accessibility (67.3%) and Agent Mastery (58.5%). It used the fewest menu layers in the sector (2.0, level with Youi), down from 3.3.

11.1% of assessed calls still weren’t answered within ten minutes, and its Engage score (31.9%) was the lowest in the sector.

Mixed results

RAC
73.1%Accessibility · #1

Led the sector on Accessibility for a fourth consecutive quarter, with the fastest average wait (0:14) and every assessed call answered.

But callers worked through the deepest phone menu in the sector (4.6 layers, up from 2.7). Overall CX fell 2.9 points to 61.1%, slipping from second to fourth.

Slipping

Allianz
▼ 5.9 ptsOverall CX

Agent Mastery fell 6.9 points to 51.5%, the lowest in the sector, with an Impact score of 51.4% against a sector average of 79.8%.

Callers who reached an agent had the sector’s best Close score (70.4%), but spent 2:29 in the phone menu, the longest of any insurer.

AAMI
53.9%Overall CX · lowest

Overall CX slipped 0.5 points, leaving AAMI last. Its Accessibility (56.2%) is the lowest in the sector, and 11.1% of assessed calls weren’t answered within ten minutes.

The conversation is improving: Agent Mastery reached a best-ever 57.6%, with the sector’s best Impact score (91.7%).

🚪 Where Callers Lose Time – Q3 2026

Where the sector is losing ground

🚪 Where Car Insurers Still Lose Time

Callers are getting through. What slows them down now is what they hear before they reach a person.

How long it takes to reach a person, split into navigating the phone menu, listening to recorded messages, and waiting for an agent:

Fastest · 2:15Budget Direct
1:40
0:19 menu · 1:40 messages · 0:16 waiting
Sector average · 2:49Australian car insurers
0:36
1:17
0:57
0:36 menu · 1:17 messages · 0:57 waiting
Slowest · 3:18Allianz
0:33
1:56
0:49
0:33 menu · 1:56 messages · 0:49 waiting
Navigating the menuRecorded messagesWaiting for an agent

Includes unanswered calls, counted up to the time limit. Totals can differ from the parts by a second because each figure is averaged separately.

Recorded messages are now the longest part of the time to reach a person. On the average call, callers spent 1:17 listening to messages, the longest on record for the sector and up for a third consecutive quarter, against 0:36 choosing options and 0:57 waiting for an agent. Budget Direct, the fastest to a person, still played 1:40 of messages.

3.2%of assessed calls weren’t answered within ten minutes, down from 4.8% in Q2.
8.7%of calls carried an access deduction, the lowest on record and a fifth consecutive decline.
3.2menu layers on average, down from 3.5 at the end of 2025 but still above 2.3 in Q4 2023.

The close is where the conversation slipped. Close fell 2.3 points to 58.5%, the only one of the five competencies to decline. Engage (43.1%) is still the lowest, despite rising 4.2 points.

Close covers the final check for questions, the thanks and the farewell: the last impression a comparison shopper takes away before deciding where to buy. See Inbound Phone Sales Training for training on the conversation itself.

💰 Cost of Unanswered Calls

Interactive · try your own numbers

💰 What Are Unanswered Quote Calls Costing Your Insurer?

Australian car insurers answered 96.8% of assessed calls within ten minutes this quarter, and the lowest answer rate was 88.9%. Put in your own numbers to see what your answer rate would cost you over a year.

Estimated value lost each year

$0

Callers not answered each month0
Who go elsewhere each year0
New customers lost each year0

Indicative only. The answer rates shown are from ACXPA mystery shopping calls in Q3 2026 (answered within ten minutes). Your own call volumes and conversion will differ.

Do you know your real answer rate for quote calls, as a customer experiences it? Your phone system counts the calls it answered. It can't tell you what the caller went through first, or how the conversation went. Benchmarking measures both, from $397 a month.

Get Car Insurance Benchmarking

Sector Trends – Australian Car Insurers (12-Month View)

How the sector’s three headline scores have moved over the last four quarters. Each bar is the average for Australian car insurers in that quarter.

Car Insurers Key Metrics - 12 Month Trend
ℹ️ How This Report Works
What the Three Scores Measure
How the Overall CX Score Is Calculated
How We Select and Score the Car Insurers We Benchmark
Unlock the full picture

Wondering how your own centre would score?

An ACXPA membership opens up the sector picture — full leaderboards, rolling trends and the performance ranges behind every number on this page.

But the sector isn't your centre. Benchmarking mystery-shops your line exactly the way we shopped theirs — starting at six unscripted calls a month, and going as deep as you need.

📉 Find out where your centre is losing marks — the phone menu, the wait, or the conversation itself
🏁 See your centre scored the same way — same method, same CX Standards, from $397 a month with no lock-in
🎚 Go as deep as it's worth — from a monthly snapshot of 23 core metrics up to full 48+ metric assessments with call recordings
Membership shows you the sector. Benchmarking shows you your own centre.
Deepen your view

, unlock richer sector insight — and get your centre measured

Upgrade to membership for full leaderboards, rolling trends, lifetime averages and the performance ranges this public snapshot leaves out.

And when you want your own numbers rather than the sector's, there are four benchmarking services to choose from — from a light monthly snapshot to a full private program built on your own KPIs.

🔍 Where you actually sit — lifetime, monthly and rolling leaderboards, not one quarter's snapshot
🎚 Pick your depth — 23 core metrics monthly from $397, or full 48+ metric assessments with recordings and evaluator notes
🎯 Measured against whoever matters — named competitors, or a private program against your own standards
Membership adds sector depth. Benchmarking is the only route to your centre's own metrics.
Turn context into action

, see the rankings for your own contact centre

Your membership already gives you the sector picture — dashboards, rolling trends and results across a selection of car insurers.

What it can't tell you is how your own centre would score if we called it. Benchmarking can, at whatever depth is worth paying for — starting at six unscripted calls a month.

📉 Know exactly where you're losing marks — every stage of the call scored, from menu design to how the agent closed, not just the three headline scores
🎚 Start light or go deep — 23 core metrics monthly from $397, up to full 48+ metric assessments with call recordings and evaluator notes
🎯 Compare against whoever matters — name the competitors you want measured, or run a private program against your own KPIs and compliance checks
✅ Know what to fix first — prioritised actions to reduce friction and lift conversion, not a wall of numbers
Membership gives you the context. Benchmarking gives you the measure.
Empower your team

Seats give your team the market. Benchmarking gives you your own numbers.

Make sure your team are using their allocated Individual Memberships — that's the full sector view, already included in what you pay.

To measure your own organisation, four benchmarking services sit behind one page, from a monthly snapshot through to a private program built on your own compliance criteria.

👥 Your team sees the market — Individual Memberships you have already paid for
📉 You see your own centre — independently mystery-shopped every month, scored against the ACXPA Contact Centre CX Standards
🎚 Scale it to the question you're answering — 23 core metrics from $397, or full 48+ metric assessments with recordings
📈 A number you can take upstairs — trend analysis that stands up in a board pack
Seats show the sector. Benchmarking measures your centre.
Demonstrate your impact

Need proof for your clients? Benchmarking delivers it

Vendor seats include Individual Member access to the sector dashboards, so you can see where the market sits before you walk into the room.

To evidence provider-level performance — or prove what your own solution changed — you need independent scoring against the ACXPA Contact Centre CX Standards, delivered on a schedule rather than as a one-off.

🔎 Independent, not self-reported — third-party assessment with your name nowhere near the scoring
📈 Before and after — monthly data that shows movement over time, not a single flattering snapshot
🎚 Sized to the engagement — a light monthly measure from $397, or full 48+ metric assessments with recordings and evaluator notes
📄 Something you can actually send a client — a report they will believe because you did not write it
Membership = sector insight. Benchmarking = measurable results.

0 Comments

Leave a reply

ACXPA Platinum Sponsor

Log in with your email address

or Become an ACXPA Member

Forgot your details?

Create Account